What the rule says. "The home care agency or home care registry may not hire, roster or retain an individual if the State Police criminal history record reveals a prohibited conviction listed in 6 Pa. Code § 15.143 (relating to facility responsibilities), or if the Department of Aging letter of determination states that the individual is not eligible for hire or roster." (611.52(e))
The 15.143 list (6 Pa. Code 15.143(a)-(c); 15.143(b)) includes:
- a felony conviction under The Controlled Substance, Drug, Device and Cosmetic Act;
- criminal homicide, aggravated assault, kidnapping and unlawful restraint;
- rape, statutory sexual assault, involuntary deviate sexual intercourse, sexual assault, aggravated indecent assault, indecent assault, indecent exposure, incest, and sexual abuse of children;
- arson, burglary and robbery;
- a felony theft offense, or two or more theft misdemeanors;
- tampering with records, endangering the welfare of children, intimidation of or retaliation against witnesses, and corruption of minors;
- similar Federal or out-of-state offenses.
That is not the whole list: 15.143(b) names 27 Crimes Code items in all. Read the full section, linked above, before you decide.
The Peake ruling. The Department of Aging says: "On December 30, 2015, the Commonwealth Court held in Peake v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, et al., 216 M.D. 2015, that the “lifetime employment ban” contained in Section 503(a) of the Older Adults Protective Services Act (“OAPSA”), 35 P.S. §10225.503(a), violates due process guarantees under the Pennsylvania Constitution and is therefore not enforceable." It adds that "criminal history background checks are still required for all applicants" (Department of Aging).
What Aging recommends. An individualized risk assessment, case by case, and advice from counsel. It says the Court’s guidance looked at factors such as "the nature of the crime; facts surrounding the conviction; time elapsed since the conviction; the evidence of the individual’s rehabilitation; the nature and requirements of the job", and that the Commonwealth decided not to appeal (Department of Aging). Questions can go to the licensing agency or Aging’s Criminal Background Record Unit, (717) 265-7887 (Department of Aging).
Our reading. DOH’s rule still prints the prohibition, and DOH’s January 2024 application asked for your policy for "prohibiting individuals with a prohibited conviction or Department of Aging ineligibility determination from being hired or rostered" (2024 application). We found nothing from DOH on how it applies 611.52(e) since Peake. So: run every check, write down how you weighed each record that matters, take legal advice before you decide, and ask DOH how it surveys these decisions. A Department of Aging letter that says someone is not eligible is a separate ground in 611.52(e).